Over the years, the natural progression for some of the Championship’s finest performers has been to move up to Premier League football after earning their stripes in English football’s second division.
Some people find it easier to take the leap of faith than others. For every Michael Olise, there is an Anthony Knockaert; thriving in the Championship does not always imply that success will be replicated at a higher level, but others can take it all in stride and outperform all expectations in the Premier League.
Many of the most accomplished and beloved players in Championship history have inevitably progressed to the Premier League. Adel Taarabt, who had arguably the best individual season in the division with 19 goals and 21 assists to lead QPR to the 2010/11 league title, played in the top flight alongside Tottenham Hotspur and Fulham, while the late, great Peter Whittingham, widely regarded as the Championship’s greatest player of all time, appeared for Cardiff City and Aston Villa.
It’s unusual for a top Championship performer to have no prior or future Premier League experience, but that’s exactly what a few players have done, prompting Football League World to consider who the best second-tier players in history are who have never reached the highest level of the domestic game.
Some of the names may surprise you, while others may change in the future. With that in mind, FLW has compiled a list of the top nine Championship players who have never played a minute of Premier League football…
9Lewis McGugan
Getting the ball going is maverick ex-midfielder Lewis McGugan, who few would argue lacked the skill to cut his teeth in the Premier League.
McGugan is most remembered for his seven-year stint at hometown club Nottingham Forest, where he made over 200 appearances and contributed 44 goals and 27 assists from centre midfield, helping the Reds return to the Championship in 2008.
McGugan, a dynamic player with deadly quality and an eye for the extraordinary, demonstrated his goalscoring prowess in the 2010/11 season, when his 13 goals and 15 assists sparked a run to the second-tier play-offs.
That season, the ex-England youth international scored one of the most memorable goals in Championship history, a spectacular 35-yard piledriver of a free kick against Ipswich Town, demonstrating a player with the talent to perform at the highest level.
Unfortunately, McGugan never quite found his footing at the City Ground and fell out of favour with various management before spending time at Watford, Sheffield Wednesday, and Northampton Town.
McGugan was also plagued by injuries, which prompted the precocious midfield starlet to retire prematurely at the age of 29 in 2017, leaving many wondering what may have been.
8Richard Keogh
Richard Keogh, a Derby County second-tier mainstay, may be plagued by the fact that he came so close to playing in the Premier League on multiple occasions.
The 26-cap ex-Republic of Ireland international, who only retired two years ago after dropping down the divisions with Wycombe Wanderers and Forest Green Rovers, got his big break when Derby County agreed a fee of more than £1 million with Coventry City following the Sky Blues’ relegation from the Championship in 2012.
Keogh was at the centre of Derby’s multiple failed promotion efforts in the 2010s. The defender famously gifted Bobby Zamora’s last-gasp winner for QPR in the 2014 Championship play-off final at Wembley Stadium, a game Derby had controlled, and the Rams also failed to reach the play-offs the following two seasons.
Wembley heartbreak returned as Frank Lampard’s side fell to Aston Villa in 2019, just months before Keogh left Pride Park after seven years and over 350 games.
Keogh wasn’t always everyone’s cup of tea, and there’s no disputing that he cost Derby a spot in the Premier League more than a decade ago, but he was one of the Championship’s most reliable central defenders for a lot of years and deserves to be included here.
7Ilias Chair
Ilias Chair, the only player on our list who is still playing in the Championship at the moment, was anticipated to have earned a big-money move to the Premier League by this point in his career, but it hasn’t always been easy for the skilled playmaker.
Chair has spent almost his entire senior career at QPR after being signed from his native Belgium, with the exception of a remarkable loan spell with then-League Two side Stevenage in the second half of the 2018/19 season, and the 28-year-old has been one of the club’s most prominent figures in recent years, making nearly 300 appearances.
Between 2019 and 2024, the 13-cap Moroccan international scored and assisted 70 times for the Hoops, establishing himself as one of the division’s most creative and skilled midfielders and sparking speculation of a move to the Premier League.
Alas, Chair is still waiting for his big break. With a low centre of gravity, scintillating flair, an excellent passing range, and a keen eye for goal at his best, the diminutive playmaker has always had the tools to go on to bigger and better things, but injuries have proven an impediment, and he was limited to just 15 appearances during the previous season as Julien Stephan’s side finished mid-table.
There’s a sense that Chair has missed the boat now, having failed to maintain his previous output and availability levels over the last two seasons, and QPR’s reliance on his services has shifted, with the likes of Rumarn Burrell, Richard Kone, and Harvey Vale only increasing their attacking influence.
6Barry Douglas
Though arguably lacking the second-tier longevity of others on this list, Barry Douglas’ skill and involvement in two successive promotion-winning squads make it surprising that the recently retired ex-full back has never played in the Premier League.
Douglas first appeared in the Championship when Wolves signed him from Turkish club Konyaspor in the summer of 2017, and the Scotsman played an important role in the Old Gold’s famous title-winning campaign, alongside Matt Doherty, Diogo Jota, and Ruben Neves, with five goals and 14 assists from left-back.
Indeed, only Robert Snodgrass of Aston Villa set up as many goals that year, but Douglas’ marauding runs and frightening deliveries were denied Premier League appearances when Nuno Espirito Santo transferred the defender to Leeds United just a year after his arrival.
In another world, Douglas may have been a big success in Marcelo Bielsa’s high-octane style. However, injuries prevented Douglas from ever completely finding his feet at Elland Road, and he was firmly second-choice to cult hero Gjanni Alioski as Leeds avenged the previous season’s infamous play-off semi-final defeat to Derby by winning the league title.
Much like Wolves, the Whites transferred Douglas upon his return to the promised land, loaning him to Blackburn Rovers before releasing him at the conclusion of his contract and swiftly rejoining Polish top-flight side Lech Poznan before announcing his retirement in April at the age of 36.
5Britt Assombalonga
When Watford opted to sign Britt Assombalonga in 2013 after a successful loan spell at Southend United, they may not have anticipated the striker’s success in the Championship.
The Congolese attacker barely started his professional career at the age of 17, but three years later he was scoring goals in League One for Peterborough United, prompting a £5.5 million move to Nottingham Forest after just one season with Posh.
Three years later, after scoring 30 goals in 69 appearances for the Tricky Trees and missing the majority of his second season at the City Ground due to a knee injury, Assombalonga was on the move again for a large fee, with Middlesbrough paying a club record £15 million to try to win promotion back to the Premier League.
Despite scoring double figures in league goals in all three of his first three seasons at the Riverside Stadium, Assombalonga never quite reached the heights expected of him on Teesside, especially in his final season with Borough, but there was every reason to believe that while he was at Forest, he’d make it to the Premier League at some point, and that could’ve been his next step.
Instead, he remained in the Championship, and it may be a case of “What if?”‘ For the former DR Congo international, not achieving his top-flight potential.
4Fernando Forestieri
Fernando Forestieri, a mercurial talent at Championship level, won promotion to the Premier League with Watford in 2015, although he never got to play at that level.
Forestieri, a rotational option for the Hornets that year, left for Sheffield Wednesday near the end of the summer transfer window despite being named to Watford’s Premier League matchday squad just a week earlier, and it was at Hillsborough that the former Italy youth international showed his best form.
After scoring 15 goals in his maiden Championship season with the Owls, many anticipated Forestieri to go up to the top flight of English football, but the greatest bid came from ambitious fellow second-tier team Derby County, who offered £7 million.
Finally, Forestieri stayed at Wednesday for five years, a period fraught with controversy.
When his tenure in South Yorkshire came to an end in 2020, it did not fully realise the Premier League potential that the forward possessed; it might, and probably should, have been very different.
3Gabriel Sara
Gabriel Sara may have only played two Championship seasons, but he was always going to leave Carrow Road if they did not return to the top tier – but the Premier League was not his destination when he left in 2024.
A total of £9.5 million was agreed upon with Sao Paulo for the midfield maestri in 2022, with no promises that he would adjust to life in Norfolk and the rigours of English football.
Sara, on the other hand, appeared too polished for the Championship, and when it came time for him to leave Carrow Road two years later, there was a realistic anticipation that not only would the Canaries profit from his skills, but the Premier League would also come knocking.
However, Sara ended up moving to Turkey. Galatasaray signed the Brazilian for about £20 million, and after becoming a fixture in the Istanbul club’s starting lineup and winning two top division titles in a row, the 27-year-old might now be on his way to the Premier League in his prime.
Until that happens, Sara stays high on this list, despite Norwich’s Championship results of 13th and sixth in his two seasons with the club.
2Ross McCormack
There are certain types of strikers who have dominated the Championship in the past but have never fully had an impact in the Premier League, such as Jordan Rhodes, David Nugent, Billy Sharp to some extent, Michael Chopra, and so on.
All of those had their chances in England’s top division, but Ross McCormack did not.
The Scotsman was linked with a move to the Premier League as early as 2009, when he was a Cardiff City player; however, a year later, Leeds got the bargain of the century when they signed the striker for £300,000 after an underwhelming second season in the Welsh capital, before selling him to Fulham for £11 million four years later.
Given the amount, you’d expect the Cottagers to be in the Premier League at the time, but they’d recently been demoted to the Championship and were counting on McCormack to get them back there.
A prolific McCormack went again two years later, this time to Aston Villa for a cost equivalent to that of Fulham, although his time at Villa Park marked the end of his usefulness at second-tier level, as he had never played in English football’s top division.
McCormack deserved an opportunity in the major leagues at the height of his skills, but it never arrived, which is unfortunate for the player.
1Jude Bellingham
The unquestionable finest Championship player who has never played in the Premier League is an obvious option.
Jude Bellingham broke into the Birmingham City first squad at the age of 16, and despite his young, he appeared to be very comfortable in the second tier, implying that he would not be staying there for long.
An initial £25 million transfer to Borussia Dortmund would be the next step in Bellingham’s rise to super-stardom, and after just three years in Germany, he became a Galactico with a move to Real Madrid for a cost that might exceed €134 million.
Bellingham has failed to reach the goalscoring heights of his debut season, when he scored 23 times, but shoulder surgery pushed his start date back to 2025-26, which may have contributed to his lack of scoring form.
Bellingham still has three years left on his contract with Madrid, and who knows whether he will extend it or stay with the Spanish giants – while a Premier League move has not yet been announced, it would be a travesty if the midfielder did not play in England’s top flight at some point, and he has plenty of years left to do so.
xz
