It is obviously difficult to compare football players from different periods, but that hasn’t stopped supporters from arguing over who was better between Mohamed Salah of Liverpool and the dependable Cristiano Ronaldo during his first spell at Manchester United.
Both wingers have undoubtedly left enduring contributions to Premier League legend, but for supporters, that is insufficient; there must be a victor in their struggle for supremacy. Even Sky Sports has parts devoted to selecting a winner.
“Premier League Ronaldo vs. Premier League Mo Salah—are you sure?” I don’t mean to offend Ronaldo. “The Premier League has never seen anything like Cristiano Ronaldo in his prime,” one visitor remarked in response to another’s criticism.
https://twitter.com/SkySports/status/1903756106100527203?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1903756106100527203%7Ctwgr%5E9a0afe380625dfafaec74cbbfef621cb6feba8ef%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.givemesport.com%2Fcristiano-ronaldo-mohamed-salah-best-season-stats-comparison%2F
Therefore, comparing each player’s finest season in the English top division is the best way to choose the victor. It’s hard to pick just one for Salah, but it’s 2024–2025, and it’s hard to overlook Ronaldo’s 2007–2008 Ballon d’Or campaign.
The Campaign of Cristiano Ronaldo in 2007–2008
The Portuguese player’s first career Ballon d’Or
Where to begin with Ronaldo’s incredible season, who was born in Madeira? For the Portuguese talisman, it was about the aesthetics, leaving the opposition in their wake and being an all-around threat. It was much more than just goals and assists.
The season started out badly as the now-40-year-old, who is considered to be among the best football players of all time, received a red card in a 1-1 draw with Portsmouth. He can transition from right flank to a position at the top of the tree with the touch of a fingertip.
However, the blazing wide man quickly demonstrated his abilities to the globe after his comeback. He scored 31 goals and provided seven assists in the Premier League, helping Ferguson and his team win the championship two points ahead of Chelsea, who finished in second place.
Cristiano Ronaldo – 2007/08 Season:pic.twitter.com/iBOuYuzgzz
— Soham. (@ronaldogoatsfc) December 29, 2024
After joining the Old Trafford team in the summer of 2003, Ronaldo scored nine goals (eight goals and one assist) in 11 games, making him a goal danger at Europe’s highest table, the Champions League. He scored against Chelsea in the final as well.
He played every minute of his team’s knockout phases, with the exception of their second-leg quarterfinal matchup with AS Roma. Despite missing his penalty in the final, his impact was undeniable throughout, particularly when he scored against the Blues in regulation time.
Ronaldo could remain optimistic despite Manchester United’s miserable FA Cup journey ending in a 1-0 loss to Portsmouth in the sixth round. He scored twice against Tottenham in the next round and once against Aston Villa in the third round.
The Campaign of Cristiano Ronaldo in 2007–2008
Rivalry
Looks
Minutes
Objectives
Helps
Minutes for each objective
The Premier League
34
2,747
31
7.
89
League of Champions
11.
1,017
8.
One
127
FA Cup
3.
270
3.
0
90
The Community Shield
One
120
0
0
0
The sum
49
4,154
42
8.
99
The Campaign of Mohamed Salah in 2024–2025
The Liverpool player has started breaking records on a regular basis.
Let’s be clear about this. We are well aware that Salah’s 2024–25 season is not yet over, and when Arne Slot’s first season as manager ends in May, his already incredible goal and assist total is expected to increase even more.
Salah’s prolific play in front of goal was crucial for Liverpool’s success up until recently, since the team’s other offensive options, such as Darwin Nunez and Diogo Jota, were not contributing much in the final third.
Although it is mathematically feasible, it is extremely unlikely that the Reds will bridge the gap with Arsenal and add a second trophy to their collection. Additionally, Salah’s goal total has been, well, amazing.
His 17 assists and 27 goals in 29 games demonstrate his impact during Slot’s first season as manager, but the Merseyside club’s difficulties have been more noticeable in other competitions.
Despite recording three goals and four assists in nine Champions League games, the Egyptian King—who is widely regarded as one of the best African football players in history—could not stop Paris Saint-Germain’s inevitable victory.
The former AS Roma star struggled in the finals. He was usually a factor in the run-up to Liverpool’s 2-1 loss to Newcastle United in the League Cup final, particularly given that he had each scored a goal and provided an assist in the semi-finals.
However, Salah’s inability to pull up trees against the Magpies cast a tiny shadow over what should have been an incredible debut season under Jurgen Klopp. In any case, he has amassed an outstanding 32 goals and 22 assists as of March 2025.
The Campaign of Mohamed Salah in 2024–2025
Rivalry
Looks
Minutes
Objectives
Helps
Minutes for each objective
The Premier League
29
2,575
27
17
95
League of Champions
9.
809
3.
4.
270
League Cup
5.
312.
2.
One
156
The sum
45
3,696
32
22
116
A Sort of Conclusion
Putting statistics aside, Ronaldo wins.
As the saying goes, only the best can master the art of goal scoring, and it’s safe to assume that Salah and Ronaldo have both succeeded in doing so. Most importantly, though, who took pleasure in the more spectacular campaign?
Salah’s goal total is somewhat higher than Ronaldo’s (32 vs. 42), but his assist total is far superior. Could this be because of the system he’s using? Ronaldo was playing with some big-game players, whereas Salah is Liverpool’s go-to man on the right flank.
Despite the statistics, the record-breaking Portugal international was undoubtedly more entertaining to watch and won the Ballon d’Or. Taking everything into account, the deity of Manchester United takes it this time. However, that does not imply that the two were not close.
xz
